Discussion in 'Logging, Mining and Industrial Railroads' started by camelot, Jan 17, 2003.
NWSL Shay Re-gears
In response to the comment/question of upgrading the MDC shay with all of the NWSL brass gears, etc., DON"T SPEND THE MONEY!!!!! There are several way to improve the running of the MDC shay without all the expense. Other than the timing of the gears, the next issue is the electical contacts, way to stiff for the engine to operate smoothly. I have several tweeks that I have perfected over the years which works great (never read the MDC Shay improvement book). In fact, one of the tweeks I have used for years, is now incorporated into the Ready-to-Run MDC shays (darn, I should have copywritten my stuff, oh well).
Email me if you would like some of these tweeks. The only NWSL item I use is the small gear box (not the bull gear). With the, I believe its the 215 gear box, the shafts diameter are reduced to 1.5 mm (barely noticable) and a firebox can be added to cover the gear box. Hope this sparks some interest in tweeks for everyone. The MDC shay is not a bad investment, just needs some help.
Try this web site, Shays with ALL kinds of stacks...............
About those "cap" spark arrestors that were talked about that you requested a picture of...here is a link to a page on my website that has a pretty good shot of this type of spark arrestor on top of McCloud River #14. The McCloud used the larger "balloon" type of stacks in earlier, wood burning days; all the oil burning locomotives (including those converted from wood) received this type of spark arrestor.
To repeate what was said...just about all wood burners had the large diamond stack, and in at least some places the use of such stacks were actually required by law on wood burning locomotives. "Straight" stacks were generally not seen on anything other than oil burners.
Hope this helps, and enjoy your model. Looks good.
Bear Traps on Shays
There were some experimental "Bear Traps" applied to shays, however, not succesful. There was not enough draw through the trap to be benificial. Most shays choked out with this design.
Of course, its your railroad, I think a "Bear Trap" would look cool on one!
MDC Shay Tweaks
My shay tweaks are in are readable now. Please Email me for the information. I have never read the "Shay" book, however, this information to my knowledge is not mentioned in the book.
For better wipers for the MDC shay, throw the ones that came with it into a bits box, and buy the "Echo Mountain" ones which are perfect.
I've not seen photos of the wipers, no photos in the catalog.
How do they attach, what gauge of phospher bronze, etc. are they made of. Anything larger than 0.010 diameter wire is too much pressure on each wheel.
If you have photos, please attach or send to me.
They come 6 on a sheet, enough for 1 shay or a three trucker.
These look pretty good. There are actually only enough for 1 MDC shay as each truck uses 2 wipers unless someone wanted to add pick-ups to the an MDC 3 truck shay. Looks like the pick-up wire is soldered to the top of the mounting area.
On my wipers, I solder 0.010 wire on the under side of the fold and bend the wire so it is between the two wheels, not pressing down on the top.
I may give these a try out.
Yes you are right, only enough for a 2 or 3 truck shay.
Toooooooo much liquid refreshment over Xmas.
Too Much Juice
I can understand that!
Johnston's book recommends trimming the "wings" of the wipers by about half of thier width. This seems to lessen friction on the wheeel treads and makes the easier to adjust them for proper tension:thumb:
Hi Eldncn, and welcome to the gauge. The Echo Mountain wipers are far better than those that come with the MDC kit, I have used the originals many times, but always found them to be too tight, when "Echo Mountain " brought out their wipers, I was very pleased with the results. no drag and perfect pickup.
I never had a problem with my RTR 2 truck in HO. Damn thing ran absolutely great out of the box.
Speaking of which, I don't understand why everyone replaces the stock wipers and pads. Mine were pretty dirty when I got it and it still ran well. I guess I got a good one out of the bunch and should consider myself lucky.
Sorry, but no, it doesn't.
#8 runs the best!
My #8 runs the best. it has a gear reduction motor, and a NWSL partial regear kit, as well as the NWSL Bull gear. When Dr Tom comes over to play trains, #8 is his preferred locomotive
here is a link to a video.
there is a glitch in the camera that gives it some perceived jerkyness, and the noise you here is from the camera. # 8 is silky smooth, very quiet, and very slow.
Yeah Ray, I wouldn't doubt that, I've seen your (Amazing) work and that fabricated gearbox is just genius. :thumb:
Separate names with a comma.